I've written before about Olympic medal tables, and one of the best things about the Winter Olympics is that they are so balanced, especially in light of the event-inflation (35 to 98 medal events from 1980 to 2014) which helps some of the less winter-centric sports nations. So it's interesting to see how various nations report the overall medals, which, remember, is never an official IOC statistic--the Olympic Committee says it would encourage nationalism, something the raising of flags and playing of anthems, or indeed the grouping of athletes by national teams of course doesn't do.
Russia 'won' the games by any measure, and in fact, IOC president Thomas Bach was quite candid in his closing speech, attributing part of the 'success' of the Games to the success of the host nation's team. Just as happened in London 2012, the triumphs of the host nation--a feat repeated regularly at Olympic Games--helped get that nation's viewers wrapped up in the competition, and the 'feel-good' factor pushed many wider issues, including those of costs of the games, financial needs elsewhere, persecution of gays, and growing crisis in Ukraine, out of sight and mind.
As well as making everyone forget the horror stories filling the world's press before the games started about hotels, transport, communications and the like, which as I pointed out at the time are also de rigeur for a bored, hyper-critical, and often unfamiliar press corps to the build up of an Olympics.
So Russia, to Bach's, Putin's, and millions of Russians' delight, 'won' the medals table. They won it no matter how you stacked it. And how you stack it is important.
In 2012, the British press inevitably ranked the table by gold medals--putting team GB & NI in third place, ahead of Russia. Here's the breakdown of the top five nations in order of golds: USA 46 China 38 GB&NI 29 Russia 24 Germany/France 11.
But if you saw a Russian paper, you might have seen the table listed by total medals, or by a simple points system; the most common being 3 for a gold, 2 for a silver, 1 for a bronze. Here's the top five nations again, listed by points (medals in parenthesis). USA (46-29-29) 225 China (38-27-23) 191 Russia (24-26-32) 156 GB&NI (29-17-19) 140 Germany (11-19-14) 85. If you weight the gold and silvers higher, using a 5-3-1 system, Russia still tops GB&NI 230-215.
Obviously, a points system favours bigger nations, with more depth of talent. There are so many anomalies already: team sports like basketball or ice hockey which produce only a single medal for the top three, sports like swimming whose gradations encourage multiple medalists, sports that have tight limits for each country's entrants and those that don't, and many many more. But if you're talking about who 'won' an Olympics, surely you need to consider all the medals? Why not consider 4th place? Or 4th through 10th?
The thing that jumps out at the 2012 games is the distance between first and second, between second and third/fourth, and between fourth and everyone else. But when you look at the Winter Games, stacked with more esoteric sports fiercely dependent on access to facilities (like mountains, snow and ice), the picture is wonderfully balanced.
Here's the gold medal table: Russia 13, Norway 11, Canada 10, USA 9, Netherlands/Germany 8, Belarus 5, Austria/France/Poland 4.
But if you're in the USA, you're more likely to see a total medals table, which looks like this: Russia 33, USA 28, Norway 26, Canada 25, Netherlands 24, Germany 19.
And if you're in Canada, I defy you to find a paper listing the medals in anything other than a points format, in which the Russians run away with the title, but Canada comes second by a nose over the arch-enemy USA. Here's how it looks in 3-2-1: Russia (13-11-9) 70 Canada (10-10-5) 55 USA (9-7-12) 53 Norway (4-5-10) 48 Netherlands (8-7-9) 24
It doesn't really matter, though, because the Olympics is all about encouraging us to get beyond national chauvinism and compete for the sake of competition, right? And if you believe that, I've got copies of the protest letters over the years about things like seams in the lycra bondage costumes speedskaters wear.
On the topic of rising above chauvinsim, recall the wonderful Dutch speedskating coach Jillert Anema (he ought to have his own sports talk show in America, Sports Anema) who accused the USA of 'failing' at the Winter Olympics because they concentrate only on their own sports which the rest of the world doesn't play. It appeared that Anema's definition of failing was 'failing at speedskating' not least because of the 24 Dutch medals, 23 came in speedskating, which has a rather limited reach in most of the world without specialist speedskating rinks, in other words, most of the world. That doesn't say much for the breadth of Dutch winter sports success.
Remember too that speedskating success is not unknown in the US (Eric Heiden, Bonnie Blair, Shanti Davis etc) though it is concentrated on one track in West Allis, Wisconsin. And Jillert was also wrong when he said the US wasn't ranked in the top 30 in the world in football (soccer), which is the (only?) other big Dutch sport (apart from korfball and fierljeppen). The US is ranked 13th in the world. Holland is ranked 10th. And we've won exactly the same number of World Cups as the Dutch.
Showing posts with label Sochi. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Sochi. Show all posts
Monday, 24 February 2014
Tuesday, 18 February 2014
COMMENTARY AS EMOTIONAL INQUISITION: WINTER OLYMPIC NOTES III
In America, Olympic broadcasting faces a slightly different problem of pitching winter sport than the BBC's, because the Olympic format of building
soap-opera 'up close and personal' storylines for every event is a
tradition more than half a century old. NBC also has the
advantage/problem of doing much of the games on tape delay. This
allows them to hold a good story as long as they'd like, up to the
very end of their prime-time broadcast, but it also tempts them into
playing with the narrative.
In 1992 NBC had come up
with the phrase 'plausibly live' to describe their tape delayed
coverage from Barcelona, and fair enough, if you keep away from the
news and the net you can watch as live. But in Atlanta in 1996 they
famously redid their gymnastics commentary to re-order the
competitors, thus increasing the tension. They provided new
commentary, which I watched them record in the now-empty Georgia Dome
(I was in charge of the basketball coverage in the other half of the
Dome). I also talked to one of the commentators, Elfie Schlegel, as
she and John Tesh walked in to do their voice-over. I wrote about
this for the Herald-Tribune after the games, and NBC's Dick Ebersol wrote an
indignant letter of protest denying what was obvious to anyone who
watched the show. Apart from the order, you could hear the basketball
horn go off. Ebersol claimed disingenuously that the horn was being tested,
which was true; what he didn't say was that we were not allowed to test it
until after the gymnastics was finished! Our half of the Dome was
required to be both dark and silent throughout actual gymnastics competition.
Anyway, this time NBC
gave into temptation on the men's figure skating. With no American
left in the running, the story was Russian veteran Evgeni Plushenko,
but he unfortunately had tweaked an injury during warmups, and
withdrawn from the event. But when, many hours later, NBC went on air
in prime time, they not only teased Plushenko's performance
throughout the night, but when it came to the moment they actually
feigned surprise at his withdrawal. Obviously it's not like
re-editing events' it's just a cynical exercise in manipulating the
audience to sit through more commercials; eminently cynical.
Though probably not as cynical as the bits that were cut from the
Opening Ceremony speeches, in particular IOC President Thomas Bach's
call for the games to be held 'with tolerance and without
discrimination for any reason,' NBC probably feared tolerance and non-discrimination might have
offended much of their audience.
But the biggest
controversy reflected NBC's overweaning determination to cast this sporting event
into the template of human-interest. Bode Miller, who's now 36 and
nearing the end of a magnificient, if sometimes controversial career,
had just taken a bronze in the Super Giant Slalom, salvaging a medal
after a disappointing downhill. He had told NBC, in an interview with
news anchor Tom Brokaw, that he was racing at this Olympics for his
brother Chalone, a snowboarder, who had died last year, aged 29.
During the race, NBC even had Miller's wife miked up, and after the finish
he was interviewed by Christin Cooper (left), a former US skier whom I'd met
a few times in the 80s.
During the race, NBC even had Miller's wife miked up, and after the finish
he was interviewed by Christin Cooper (left), a former US skier whom I'd met
a few times in the 80s.
Miller's answer to
Cooper's first question said he had a 'lot of emotion riding on it',
and she then followed up with a question that was classic action news
at 8 stick the microphone into the crying victim's face and ask:
'Bode, you’re showing so much emotion down here, what’s going
through your mind?' I don't think Christin, who was friendly,
articulate and smart as a skier, was wrong to ask that question—she
commented on his emotion. But the question itself is far too
lax—what's going through your mind?—to necessarily get a good answer.
Bode's answer was general, so Cooper had to press on, trying to get him to
mention his brother. And as tears began to appear, Miller produced an
amazing response: he didn't know if the emotion was for his brother or for
himself.
Done, brilliant, he's
given you gold, he's crying, now move on, or out. Instead, Cooper
started fishing for an angelic moment—Miller had been looking into
the sky before his run. She was asking him to become part of a daytime TV movie. Miller was unable to answer, but the camera
zoomed in on him, and his tears, holding him in extreme close up as if trying to focus on each individual droplet. They then followed Miller as he went off to be by himself, and Dan Hicks picked up and tried to
explain the situation. Hicks did his best not to pander,
but having built up a soap-opera scenario, there was no way NBC were
going to desert the soap opera money shot: tears are the currency of
voyeurism, the ultimate proof of 'real' emotion on the screen, and they need to be seen up extremely up close and personal.
I'm not criticising
Christin Cooper for what was Oprah-esque overkill—and neither did
Miller, who defended her afterwards and spoke of being caught up in
the emotion of the moment. NBC, of course, immediately used that as a justification, saying that they supported 'the line of questioning' (no mention of sticking with his reaction) and claiming Miller had been 'supportive of ...the overall interview', which he wasn't.
The producer in the truck could have left the scene gracefully, dissolved to Miller's run perhaps, or simply moved on to the next story. Cooper got a human reaction from Miller, but no one was content with that. There had to be more, so the audience could get their vicarious pleasure. It was great TV for an instant, and it became embarrassing for a lot longer.
Christin Cooper for what was Oprah-esque overkill—and neither did
Miller, who defended her afterwards and spoke of being caught up in
the emotion of the moment. NBC, of course, immediately used that as a justification, saying that they supported 'the line of questioning' (no mention of sticking with his reaction) and claiming Miller had been 'supportive of ...the overall interview', which he wasn't.The producer in the truck could have left the scene gracefully, dissolved to Miller's run perhaps, or simply moved on to the next story. Cooper got a human reaction from Miller, but no one was content with that. There had to be more, so the audience could get their vicarious pleasure. It was great TV for an instant, and it became embarrassing for a lot longer.
Labels:
Bode Miller
,
Christin Cooper
,
Dan Hicks
,
NBC
,
Sochi
,
Winter Olympics
Monday, 17 February 2014
COMMENTARY AND CHEERLEADING: WINTER OLYMPIC NOTES II
The Winter Olympics is
a good way for us to test the quality of commentators, because in
both the UK and USA most of the sports are not things television
covers regularly, and they are not sports with which the audiences
are familiar. Figure skating has a wide appeal; when I worked for ABC
and we were programming the Calgary games, we aimed for figure
skating and the US hockey team for our prime times every night. The
skating would rate about 50% higher—remember hockey is basically a
regional thing in the US, while skating has the broad, cross-gender
appeal that made gymnastics such a big thing in the post-Korbut,
Comaneci era.
Figure skating is
basically bowling alley ballet, a sport with the dual drawbacks of
first requiring make-up, sequinned costumes, music and choreographers
to perform and second being subject to judging, with all its
attendant history of corruption and fraud. Yet if anything, skating
is more popular now than ever, thanks to 'talent' shows like Dancing
On Ice. When you think about it, the Olympic format is almost as
close to Ted Mack's Amateur Hour as Dancing, or Strictly, or X
Factor. The biggest difference being the figure skating judges are
locked into a 1950s aesthetic, and susceptible to bribes, but are not
fed clever lines by the producers for the audience's entertainment.
If anything though, the 'kiss and cry' area at the Olympics is even
more OTT than X Factor.
When I covered Lake
Placid, there were 35 medal events; in Sochi there are 98. Sports
have been expanded, not often for the better (cf: classic vs
freestyle cross country skiing; 'team' figure skating) and new sports
have been added, including more judged sports, like freestyle skiing
and snowboarding. Of course there are also a couple of events that
excite me the way roller derby did when I was 11 years old:
short track speedskating and snowboard cross, which are basically the
same kind of Ben Hur races, one on ice and the other on snow. But
with new sports has come a new, younger audience and a problem for
commentators, as I've been discovering watching the BBC coverage.
Snowboarding is
analogous to surfing, and the lingo seems to have been built on a
gnarly surf base. But surfing has never been in danger of reaching
the Olympics. Snowboarding is one of the few sports at the Winter Olympics where the competitors don't dress in lycra bondage gear, and the only one where a competitor (in Vancouver) was barred from the games after testing positive for marijuana, which would imply that it is the only sport where pot is a performance enhancing drug. So it's a young, groovy thing, which means BBC
commentators appear to be determined to do the verbal equivalent of a
1440 Yolo flip on every routine. This Jonathan Pearce approach might
work on radio, and attract a lot of attention, but it doesn't do much
to enlighten the audience. On the other hand, I once asked a snowboarder,
while I was doing commentary at the 2005 Winter University Games, what
'huge air' meant, and he said, 'well, like, the air, it was huge'. So
now we knew.
On the other hand,
you'd think curling would be a natural fit, partly because the
Scottish (whoops, I mean British) teams are quite good, and partly
because it has the same sort of appeal as snooker, lawn bowls, or
even darts. Which means the BBC commentators approach each end with a
sort of genteel calm, regardless of how tight the competition is, and
even in celebration of a British win have all the reserve of Phil
Drabble commiserating with the second place finisher at a sheepdog
trial. What would be instructive would be to swap the snowboarding
and curling commentary teams around, if only for a day.
Meanwhile, Great Britain & Northern Ireland picked up its first gold medal Friday, in skeleton, and I watched
Lizzy Yarnold's impressive win to prepare myself for chat on Saturday morning's
World Service Weekend programme. Skeleton bob is basically going down
a bobsled run on a sled, head first the way you would on your own
Flexible Flyer as a kid.
It's been in the Olympics before, on the
Cresta run in St. Moritz, and it's probably the most accessible and
human of the bob run events: the bobsled itself being conducted
inside a bumper car, while the luge, in Tony Kornhesier's great
phrase, resembling Dracula going downhill in his coffin.
It's been in the Olympics before, on the
Cresta run in St. Moritz, and it's probably the most accessible and
human of the bob run events: the bobsled itself being conducted
inside a bumper car, while the luge, in Tony Kornhesier's great
phrase, resembling Dracula going downhill in his coffin.
I caught the last of
the four skeleton runs, and it was gripping stuff—with the
difference of third and fourth places coming down to .04 seconds
(four one-hundreths of one second) over the combined FOUR runs. But when it got to
Yarnold and the final run, there was little grip left. She had built
up a huge (0.78 seconds!) lead over the first three runs: all she
really needed to do was get to the bottom without crashing to win.
This was pointed out,
hesitantly by Amy Williams, the skeleton expert commentator, which
then set Colin Bryce off into a mad effort to rebuild the tension.
Fair enough, because the pair had been pretty good in explaining how
the event worked, and the way in which Britain, just like East
Germany thirty years ago, had identified athletes to draft into the
sport and concentrated on sled technology, so despite not having a track
of their own to practice on they had achieved remarkable success. They
also drifted into those areas that make you wonder what 'experts' are
for. Yes, the racers will enjoy the podium, they will be happy, and
yes, they'd really like to win. You do not have to have raced at Olympic level to
provide such insights. But once the race started, all explanation was
off anyway. 'Speed will be crucial here,' said Bryce, which was
self-evident enough, but actually wasn't the most crucial thing. Then
he pulled out the commentator's greatest enemy, the cliché's cliché,
just before the start. 'Lizzie GOES FOR GOLD FOR BRITAIN' he said, a
verbal tabloid headline simple enough for any audience to understand.
The rest of the run was
basically Amy Williams cheering Lizzy down the course. This raises
the interesting point of why you need an expert commentator to cheer.
Why not have Lizzie's husband, or grandmother, or next-door-neighbor,
or Brian Blessed instead? At one point Bryce
interjected 'she's flying now', which was daring in the sense that he
didn't have David Vine's Ski Sunday tape delay to prove him hundreths
of a second right, but basically anyone going down a bob run on a
skeleton is figuratively flying. It is a difficult thing: momentum means some bumps will slow you down less than you might think, and there's no way for the naked eye to calculate how many hundreths of a second may have been gained or lost. Yarnold won by almost a full second (0.96) but remember that's a full second after FOUR runs. And as she celebrated, Amy
Williams was 'crying for her, crying for everyone' which maybe Brian
Blessed could not have done better, and I appreciated her tears for me.
Yarnold herself seems
completely likeable, a great person for a great story, and I suppose
we can expect the Seoul Hockey Syndrome to mean she will appear on a
lot more BBC in the future than she has in the past. But I was amused
by her nickname, which is 'The Yarnold'. I have written before about
the remarkable flatness of British nicknames. If Mean Joe Green had
been British, his nickname would have been 'Greeners'. Cool Papa Bell
would have been 'Bellsy'. And Broadway Joe Namath would have been
lucky to be 'Joe'. Or maybe 'The Namath'.
Labels:
Amy Williams
,
BBC
,
Brian Blessed
,
Colin Bryce
,
Lizzy Yarnold
,
Sochi
,
Winter Olympics
Sunday, 16 February 2014
SOCHI AND SOCHI: SELLING THE WINTER OLYMPICS
I was on BBC World Service Weekend yesterday, (one can find it with great difficulty at the new look IPlayer for the rest of this week) and one of the topics we discussed was the Winter Olympics--the focus was on the language of snowboarding and freestyle skiing, and I was able to describe my experience working with a barely articulate snowboarder as my analyst at the 2005 Winter University Games (this is the only Olympic sport where a competitor has been banned for testing positive for marijuana as a performance enchancing drug) and I also mentioned how many changes to the programme there have been since I first covered the games, shooting on 16mm film, at Lake Placid. To prepare for the show, I'd also made sure to watch Britain's Lizzy Yarnold win the skeleton bob.
Then I managed to get home, despite the best efforts of South West Trains, in time to watch the last period, overtime, and shootout of the Russia-USA hockey game, which was the kind of brilliance that reminded me why I've loved hockey, which my dad played, for most of my life. A friend who was watching her first-ever game was texting me with questions (and score updates) on the train, and the sport picked up at least one more fan.
So for the next few days I'll post a few thoughts on the Winter Olympics,starting with an overview now....
THE WINTER OLYMPICS:
The ten Olympics I've covered include three winter games (Placid, Sarajevo, and Calgary). I also did hockey commentary on a fourth Olympics from a studio in Paris, as well as virtually all the sports at those University Games in Austria. I worked on the 1980s full spectrum of winter sports for ABC, everything from the downhill at Kitzbuehl to ice speedway to a Brian Boitano/Katarina Witt version of Ice Capades (ah, the stories I could tell...)
Before every Olympics the media's stories are always the same, especially because the huge press corps descending (or ascending, in the case of skiing) on the games is made up of people who aren't necessarily used to covering such events. Hence the usual pre-Olympic make-news stories, like accommodation (none for the public, substandard for the press), weather (too hot in summer, either too hot or too cold but never just right in winter), snow (too much/not enough/artificial), security (the increase in Sochi reminds me of the steps 'forward' in Sarajevo, and ties in nicely with the NSA/GCHQ trend of modern life) and of course transport (traffic nightmares that didn't happen in LA and Seoul, malfunctioning press buses most memorably in Placid and Atlanta) are intensified. That a giant bus system has teething problems its first day, especially in winter conditions, is never an excuse. Dick Young of the New York Daily News was so incensed by having to wait half an hour in frozen Lake Placid the day before the games opened he was still writing about it when the Miracle On Ice happened!
Winter sports have a limited universe, and winter games often took place in small ski resort areas used to providing skiers with a good time (cf Lillehammer). But when I covered Lake Placid, there were 35 medal events; in Sochi there are 98. This proliferation demands more facilities and more infrastructure, and insures more journalists venturing into territory like biathalon or luge for the very first time. There are sports like speed skating or bobsled where competitors in bondage costumes race against the clock, there are others where awards for best make-up, choreography, or costumes, if not congeniality, ought to be worth separate medals.
Sometimes, before a games, there is political coverage of the host nation--though it has to be said that historically the IOC has always welcomed what Jeanne Kirkpatrick would call 'authoritarian governments' to host games--allocation of resources is so much easier, specially when they're being allocated to various IOC dignitaries with their hands out and pockets open. Although Russia's repressive anti-gay laws have been a focus of coverage, though rarely with reference to figure skating, the actual presentation of Putinesque politics has been very lean, and in America they've been heavily tinged with Cold War overtones. Maybe they were trying to make the Russia-USA hockey match seem more interesting.
But the odd thing is how quickly that coverage disappears once the sport actually begins. Horrible hotels, bumbling buses, civil rights for gays, Chechen terrorists, all get buried under an avalanche of frenzy as each nation's athletes compete (or 'go for gold' as you are required to say in Britain), and everyone falls in love briefly with slope style, or in the case of Britain, skeleton, which, if Seoul Hockey Syndrome is any guideline, will now slide into BBC TV schedules for the next four years, until disappointment at the next winter games drives it out. After the usual stories about transport, weather, hotels and so on repeat themselves.
Then I managed to get home, despite the best efforts of South West Trains, in time to watch the last period, overtime, and shootout of the Russia-USA hockey game, which was the kind of brilliance that reminded me why I've loved hockey, which my dad played, for most of my life. A friend who was watching her first-ever game was texting me with questions (and score updates) on the train, and the sport picked up at least one more fan.
So for the next few days I'll post a few thoughts on the Winter Olympics,starting with an overview now....
THE WINTER OLYMPICS:
The ten Olympics I've covered include three winter games (Placid, Sarajevo, and Calgary). I also did hockey commentary on a fourth Olympics from a studio in Paris, as well as virtually all the sports at those University Games in Austria. I worked on the 1980s full spectrum of winter sports for ABC, everything from the downhill at Kitzbuehl to ice speedway to a Brian Boitano/Katarina Witt version of Ice Capades (ah, the stories I could tell...)
Before every Olympics the media's stories are always the same, especially because the huge press corps descending (or ascending, in the case of skiing) on the games is made up of people who aren't necessarily used to covering such events. Hence the usual pre-Olympic make-news stories, like accommodation (none for the public, substandard for the press), weather (too hot in summer, either too hot or too cold but never just right in winter), snow (too much/not enough/artificial), security (the increase in Sochi reminds me of the steps 'forward' in Sarajevo, and ties in nicely with the NSA/GCHQ trend of modern life) and of course transport (traffic nightmares that didn't happen in LA and Seoul, malfunctioning press buses most memorably in Placid and Atlanta) are intensified. That a giant bus system has teething problems its first day, especially in winter conditions, is never an excuse. Dick Young of the New York Daily News was so incensed by having to wait half an hour in frozen Lake Placid the day before the games opened he was still writing about it when the Miracle On Ice happened!
Winter sports have a limited universe, and winter games often took place in small ski resort areas used to providing skiers with a good time (cf Lillehammer). But when I covered Lake Placid, there were 35 medal events; in Sochi there are 98. This proliferation demands more facilities and more infrastructure, and insures more journalists venturing into territory like biathalon or luge for the very first time. There are sports like speed skating or bobsled where competitors in bondage costumes race against the clock, there are others where awards for best make-up, choreography, or costumes, if not congeniality, ought to be worth separate medals.
Sometimes, before a games, there is political coverage of the host nation--though it has to be said that historically the IOC has always welcomed what Jeanne Kirkpatrick would call 'authoritarian governments' to host games--allocation of resources is so much easier, specially when they're being allocated to various IOC dignitaries with their hands out and pockets open. Although Russia's repressive anti-gay laws have been a focus of coverage, though rarely with reference to figure skating, the actual presentation of Putinesque politics has been very lean, and in America they've been heavily tinged with Cold War overtones. Maybe they were trying to make the Russia-USA hockey match seem more interesting.
But the odd thing is how quickly that coverage disappears once the sport actually begins. Horrible hotels, bumbling buses, civil rights for gays, Chechen terrorists, all get buried under an avalanche of frenzy as each nation's athletes compete (or 'go for gold' as you are required to say in Britain), and everyone falls in love briefly with slope style, or in the case of Britain, skeleton, which, if Seoul Hockey Syndrome is any guideline, will now slide into BBC TV schedules for the next four years, until disappointment at the next winter games drives it out. After the usual stories about transport, weather, hotels and so on repeat themselves.
Subscribe to:
Posts
(
Atom
)